# Caddy Firewall Policies — Missing and Incorrect Rules

> [!NOTE]
> For the complete list of custom firewall rules, see [firewall-rules.md](firewall-rules.md).

Audit findings from the zone policy review. Apply these in UniFi
**Settings → Policy Engine → Policy Table** in the order shown. All
custom policies must be above the built-in `Block All Traffic` terminal
rule.

---

## 0. Immediate Cleanup — Redundant and Incorrect Rules

Sort these out before adding anything new.

### Delete — completely redundant

| Policy | Why |
|---|---|
| `Allow CADDY to Gateway DNS` | The Caddy Pi's `resolv.conf` points to Technitium at `10.0.10.5` (TRUSTED). `Allow CADDY to DNS` already covers that. The UDM Gateway DNS forwarder is not in use. |

### Keep — intra-zone rules that are actually required

UniFi's documentation implies intra-zone traffic is allowed by default, but in practice this does **not** apply to custom zones — removing these breaks intra-zone traffic.

| Policy | Why to keep |
|---|---|
| `Allow TRUSTED to TRUSTED Any` | Without this rule, devices within TRUSTED cannot reach each other (confirmed: removing it broke SSH to Technitium). |
| `Allow IoT to IoT Any` | Same — IoT intra-zone traffic requires an explicit allow for custom zones. |

### Fix — wrong action

| Policy | Problem | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| `Allow FAMILY to CADDY` | Action is set to **Block** instead of Allow. FAMILY devices cannot reach Caddy at all. | Edit the policy and change Action to **Allow**. |

### Review — direct pinholes that bypass Caddy

These work but contradict the network design (§7.3/7.4), which says MEDIA
and FAMILY should only reach internal services through Caddy. Once the
`ALLOW CADDY to arr stack` backend policy (§2 below) is in place, both
zones can reach Emby via `emby.yourdomain.com` through Caddy instead.

| Policy | Impact of keeping | Impact of removing |
|---|---|---|
| `Allow MEDIA to Emby` | Apple TV can connect directly to LXC — wider attack surface, bypasses Caddy logging and auth. | Apple TV must use `emby.yourdomain.com` via Caddy. Requires Caddy backend policy in place first. |
| `Allow FAMILY to EMBY` | Family devices bypass Caddy for Emby. | Family devices must use `emby.yourdomain.com` via Caddy. Requires Caddy backend policy in place first. |

Remove these only **after** the `ALLOW CADDY to arr stack` policy is
created and confirmed working.

---

## 1. Fix: Allow FAMILY to CADDY (currently set to Block)

The existing `Allow FAMILY to CADDY` policy has **Action = Block**. Edit
it and change the action to **Allow**.

| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Name | `Allow FAMILY to CADDY` |
| Action | **Allow** (currently wrong — set to Block) |
| Source zone | `FAMILY` |
| Source IP | Any |
| Destination zone | `CADDY` |
| Destination IP | Any |
| Destination port | `443` |
| Protocol | TCP |

---

## 2. CADDY → TRUSTED Backend App Policies

Caddy at `10.0.15.5` cannot proxy to any backend apps in the TRUSTED zone
until these policies exist. Create one policy per row.

Every policy in this table uses:

- **Action:** Allow
- **Source zone:** `CADDY`
- **Source IP:** `10.0.15.5`
- **Destination zone:** `TRUSTED`
- **Protocol:** TCP

| Policy name | Destination IP | Destination port(s) | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| `ALLOW CADDY to arr stack` | `10.0.10.20` | `5055,6767,7878,8000,8080,8096,8191,8282,8989,9696` | Arr-stack LXC (bazarr, radarr, gluetun, qbittorrent, emby, flaresolverr, sabnzbd, sonarr, prowlarr, seerr) |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Technitium UI` | `10.0.10.5` | `5380` | Technitium admin UI |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Proxmox` | `10.0.10.10` | `8006` | Proxmox VE |
| `ALLOW CADDY to PBS` | `10.0.10.8` | `8007` | Proxmox Backup Server |
| `ALLOW CADDY to LAN web devices` | `10.0.1.6` | `80` | Lite-8 PoE switch UI |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Beszel` | `10.0.10.13` | `8090` | Beszel monitoring |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Gramps` | `10.0.10.17` | `80` | Gramps Web |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Immich` | `10.0.10.15` | `2283` | Immich |
| `ALLOW CADDY to IT Tools` | `10.0.10.7` | `80` | IT Tools |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Paperless` | `10.0.10.11` | `8000` | Paperless-ngx |
| `ALLOW CADDY to YTD` | `10.0.10.14` | `3087` | Youtarr |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Bento PDF` | `10.0.10.6` | `8080` | Bento PDF |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Koffan` | `10.0.10.12` | `8080` | Koffan (LXC 111) |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Hermes` | `10.0.10.19` | `9119` | Hermes Agent dashboard (LXC 113) |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Forgejo` | `10.0.10.18` | `3000` | Forgejo (LXC 114) |

---

## 3. CADDY → IoT Backend Policies

Caddy cannot proxy to Home Assistant or Zigbee until these exist.

Every policy in this table uses:

- **Action:** Allow
- **Source zone:** `CADDY`
- **Source IP:** `10.0.15.5`
- **Destination zone:** `IoT`
- **Protocol:** TCP

| Policy name | Destination IP | Destination port(s) | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| `ALLOW CADDY to Home Automation` | `10.0.30.6` | `8080,8123` | Zigbee2MQTT and Home Assistant |
| `ALLOW CADDY to Zigbee` | `10.0.30.5` | `80` | SLZB-06U Zigbee coordinator UI |

---

## 4. Public DNS Block Policies (per zone)

Without these, devices can bypass Technitium by querying public resolvers
(`8.8.8.8`, `1.1.1.1`, etc.) directly. Place each policy **above** the
broad `External` allow for its zone.

Every policy in this table uses:

- **Action:** Block
- **Source IP:** Any
- **Destination zone:** `External`
- **Destination IP:** Any
- **Protocol:** TCP/UDP
- **Destination port:** `53`

| Policy name | Source zone |
|---|---|
| `BLOCK FAMILY public DNS` | `FAMILY` |
| `BLOCK MEDIA public DNS` | `MEDIA` |
| `BLOCK IoT public DNS` | `IoT` |
| `BLOCK GUEST public DNS` | `GUEST` |

---

## Policy Order Reference

Within each zone's rule set, the evaluation order must be:

```
specific allows (DNS, DHCP, Caddy, app pinholes)
public DNS block (above the External allow)
External allow
Gateway DHCP allow
Gateway block
Block All Traffic  ← built-in terminal rule
```

If a broad block rule sits above a specific allow, the block wins and the
intended traffic is dropped. Use **Reorder** in UniFi to verify positions
after adding new policies.